The Police, the Legal Service, and the Ministries of Justice and Transport expressed their disagreement with the bill proposed by AKEL MP Andreas Pasiourtidis, which provides for the cancellation of the out-of-court settlement of fines not served within 180 days of the commission of the violation.
The proposal was put up for discussion today before the parliamentary Transport Committee, with the relevant authorities warning of additional burdens on the courts, increased administrative costs, and potential impacts on road safety.
According to the proposed regulation, notice of an out-of-court fine must be served mandatorily within 180 days from the date the offense was committed. Otherwise, the possibility of an out-of-court settlement will cease to apply, without, however, lifting the criminal liability of the offender, who will be referred to court.
Justifying his proposal, Mr. Pasiourtidis argued that the existing system for serving out-of-court fines by traffic cameras shows serious malfunctions, which have been consistently attempted to address through piecemeal interventions.
"The bill is based on the fact that today, by common acceptance, the system for serving extrajudicial notices from the cameras is distorted, ineffective, and we are constantly trying to rationalize it with piecemeal solutions," he said.
"If the Police cannot serve a fine within six months, then there is no reason for it to exist," he added, clarifying that cancelling the out-of-court procedure does not imply exemption from criminal liability.
Changes to penalty scores as well
The second part of the bill concerns the time from which penalty points imposed on drivers are calculated.
Specifically, in cases where the offender pays the out-of-court fine and accepts the penalty points, these will be considered imposed from the date the offense was committed and not from a later period.
Conversely, if the driver fails to pay the fines and the case goes to court, penalty points will be calculated from the date the court sentence is imposed.
Warnings about overburdening the courts
During the discussion, the Ministry of Justice expressed its disagreement with the proposed regulation, arguing that instead of facilitating offenders, it may impose additional burdens.
A Ministry spokesperson argued that losing the possibility of an out-of-court settlement after the 180-day period will deprive drivers of the opportunity to settle their violation without legal proceedings.
As he explained, these cases will be referred directly to the courts, further burdening their already increased schedule. At the same time, he estimated that implementing the regulation will bring additional administrative costs to the Police.
Risk of deliberate avoidance of receiving extrajudicial notices
Similar reservations were expressed by the Director of the Traffic Police Department of the Headquarters, Haris Evripidou, who warned that the cancellation of the formal notice may encourage citizens to avoid collecting it.
In his statement, he argued that introducing new regulations into procedures that should already be functioning effectively may create more problems than those attempted to be resolved.
At the same time, he pointed out that implementing both provisions of the bill will require modifications to the Police's electronic systems that handle out-of-court fines, increasing both administrative and financial costs.
The Ministry of Transport adopted the positions of the Police.
Effects on the deterrent nature of penalties
The Legal Service also expressed its disagreement, raising issues both regarding the practical implementation of the proposed legislation and the deterrent nature of the penalties.
As noted, the cancellation of the possibility of an out-of-court settlement after the 180-day period essentially abolishes a more favourable procedure for the offender, leading them directly before the Justice system.
Particular reservations were also raised about the proposed change in the calculation of penalty points. According to the Legal Service, the regulation may weaken the system's preventive and deterrent nature.
He also warned that cases may arise of drivers who will continue to drive on the roads, even though, based on their penalty points, they should not be driving.
The proposal will be submitted to the Plenary
Despite the objections, Andreas Pasiourtidis made it clear that he intends to proceed with the bill so that it can be brought before the Plenary of Parliament for a vote.
Finally, responding to the objections raised, he criticized the Police's stance, arguing that every time he disagrees with a proposed change, he cites the increased cost of implementation.
