By Ken Silverstein
In less than seven weeks, the last long-term contracts for supplying Russian liquefied natural gas (LNG) to Europe will cease to be valid. Buyers in France and Spain still want to supply this particular gas. The European Union, however, decided to ban it. The ban comes into effect on January 1st, amid the toughest winter for the European natural gas market since the start of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
This is the moment when Europe is called upon to face the cost of its choices and, above all, the principles it has decided to defend.
Russia invaded Ukraine unprovoked, and Europe decided to stop funding the Russian war machine through natural gas purchases. Now, with the war in Iran putting additional pressure on the global energy supply, Europe still buys certain quantities of Russian gas, but has now institutionalized its full decoupling.
At the same time, Washington is easing sanctions against Moscow. Europe has chosen the right side of History. However, to effectively support this stance, it needs not only American LNG but also a US president who values his country's allies more than authoritarian leaders.
"Europe should not buy even a single molecule of Russian natural gas again," said European Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen in March, just weeks after the closure of the Channel of Hormuz and the surge in natural gas prices. As he claimed, Russia had turned energy into a tool of blackmail against Europe.
It's easy to forget how far Europe has come. Before the Russian invasion, Russia supplied the EU with 152 billion cubic meters of natural gas annually, an amount corresponding to about 45% of its total imports. By 2025, supplies had been reduced to 36 billion cubic meters, that is 12% of imports.
However, 12% still represents significant revenue for the Kremlin. Last year, EU member states spent about 6.7 billion dollars for Russian natural gas via pipelines and an additional 7.6 billion dollars for Russian LNG. In total, about 14 billion dollars ended up in the coffers of a government at war with a European neighboring country.
The new European legislative framework now reduces these transactions to zero.
The EU banned short-term LNG supply contracts in April and the corresponding pipeline gas contracts in June. Long-term LNG contracts expire on January 1. For long-term pipeline natural gas contracts, the deadline is September 30, 2027, or, at the latest, November 1 of the same year, if any country faces difficulties replenishing its reserves.
At the same time, the EU has closed the interim "windows": after the ban comes into effect, European companies will no longer be allowed to buy, sell, or transport Russian LNG anywhere in the world.
The most significant legal challenge to the decision is now before the judiciary. Hungary and Slovakia, which continue to supply Russian natural gas via the TurkStream pipeline under the Black Sea, have separately appealed to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Slovakia, as well as the previous government of Hungary, argue that the ban essentially constitutes a sanction and, therefore, should have been unanimously approved by the member states. However, the Court often takes years to issue rulings in such cases, while the ban remains in effect until the judicial process is completed.
Where will Europe get natural gas from?
The answer is mainly from the United States. And that was exactly what President Trump was asking for.
Last year, from the United Nations podium, the American president accused his NATO allies of "funding their own war" by buying Russian energy, and threatened to impose tariffs if they did not stop.
At the same time, as part of the trade agreement concluded by Washington and Brussels in July 2025, the European Union committed to purchasing American energy worth 750 billion dollars.
In the first half of 2026, the US covered 59% of the EU's LNG imports.
The Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis estimates that the United States will surpass Norway this year and become Europe's largest natural gas supplier. At the same time, it predicts that by 2028 they will cover up to 80% of the Union's LNG imports.
Europe therefore did what Trump demanded. However, he then chose to ease the pressure on Moscow himself.
Two different directions
Europe is tightening the institutional framework, while Washington is easing restrictions through presidential decisions.
In March, as the war in Iran led to a surge in oil prices, the Trump administration temporarily lifted sanctions on Russian oil. The President of the European Council, António Costa, described the decision as "particularly worrying," highlighting its impact on European security.
The easing of restrictions continued. Subsequently, the U.S. government extended the exemption from sanctions for Russian diesel exports until April 2027.
On October 16, Trump suspended the implementation of the Lindsey O. Graham Act to impose sanctions on Russia and Iran, which he had signed just a month earlier.
This law provided for imposing 500% tariffs on Russian products and 100% tariffs on the largest buyers of Russian energy.
Kirill Dmitriev, Putin's envoy for investment affairs, welcomed the decision, calling it a "truly historic moment."
That same month, European Energy Commissioner Dan Jørgensen moved in the opposite direction. In statements to Hungarian media, he made it clear that the EU will maintain the ban even if Russia and Ukraine reach a peace agreement.
Talks mediated by the US resumed this month in Abu Dhabi. Moscow, however, continues to reject the ceasefire and demands that Ukraine hand over territories it still controls.
The contrast between the two approaches is especially significant when one considers who is the aggressor and who is the defender. Ukraine defends its territorial integrity and democracy against a country that invaded its territory.
However, Washington has repeatedly portrayed Volodymyr Zelensky as an obstacle to achieving peace. The Ukrainian president called Trump's decision to suspend the implementation of the Graham sanctions a mistake, predicting that the same policy will continue.
"The easing of sanctions will continue," he warned.
The U.S. government argues that the exemptions from sanctions are justified by the need to contain fuel prices. However, the midterm elections in the US have now concluded, and the political management of prices at the pump can no longer explain this choice on its own.
What remains is a series of decisions that reduce the pressure on the attacker, while the victim of the invasion continues to fight.
Of course, Europe is not in a position to criticize without taking its own contradictions into account.
From January to October, European ports received 14 million tons of LNG from Russia's Yamal unit in the Arctic, worth about 10 billion dollars. This is a quantity that exceeds all European country purchases from this unit throughout 2025.
Buyers rushed to build stock ahead of the ban. Indicatively, between January and May, imports of Russian natural gas via pipelines increased by 7%, while LNG imports increased by 11%.
Last year, Belgium covered 40% of its LNG imports from Russia, with a significant portion of the quantities entering through the port of Zeebrugge.
At the same time, the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis warns that Europe risks replacing one energy dependence with another: exchanging Russian natural gas for American gas.
A few years ago, such a warning would have seemed almost absurd. American support for Europe was unquestioned, and no one equated Washington's actions with those of Moscow.
The fact that today there are voices making such comparisons says less about Europe's choices and much more about America's stance.
All of these are valid observations. However, they do not change the fact that Europe is moving in the right direction.
Europe insists on its line
Europe has reduced its dependence on Russian natural gas from nearly half of its total imports to one-eighth, and has now established a specific timetable for their complete elimination.
This choice comes at a real cost.
Natural gas prices on European energy exchanges reached their highest level since late 2022 this autumn, while inventories at storage facilities at the start of the heating season reached historic lows.
Yet, the EU refuses to open the tap of Russian natural gas again.
Energy dependence on the United States should, theoretically, be clearly less problematic. Buying natural gas from an ally is not the same as buying it from a country bombing the energy infrastructure of a friendly neighboring state.
However, this new energy relationship with the US can only work if Washington behaves as an ally.
In reality, Europe's stance toward Putin now passes through American LNG terminals. The president who controls this energy lever can either use it to support democracies resisting Russian aggression or turn it into just another bargaining chip in his dealings with Moscow.
Dan Jørgensen clearly summarized Europe's choice, emphasizing that Europeans must stand "shoulder to shoulder against Putin, to help our friends in Ukraine."
The United States used to say the same thing — and mean it.
Russia started this war. Europe chose to stop funding it through purchases of Russian natural gas, at a time when it has resources to help Ukraine defend itself.
Whether this option will survive the winter now depends less on Brussels and more on Washington. And, above all, whether America will remember which side it is supposed to defend.
Forbes
This choice comes at a real cost.
Natural gas prices on European energy exchanges reached their highest level since late 2022 this autumn, while inventories at storage facilities at the start of the heating season reached historic lows.
Yet, the EU refuses to open the tap of Russian natural gas again.
Energy dependence on the United States should, theoretically, be clearly less problematic. Buying natural gas from an ally is not the same as buying it from a country bombing the energy infrastructure of a friendly neighboring state.
However, this new energy relationship with the US can only work if Washington behaves as an ally.
In reality, Europe's stance toward Putin now passes through American LNG terminals. The president who controls this energy lever can either use it to support democracies resisting Russian aggression or turn it into just another bargaining chip in his dealings with Moscow.
Dan Jørgensen clearly summarized Europe's choice, emphasizing that Europeans must stand "shoulder to shoulder against Putin, to help our friends in Ukraine."
The United States used to say the same thing — and mean it.
Russia started this war. Europe chose to stop funding it through purchases of Russian natural gas, at a time when it has resources to help Ukraine defend itself.
Whether this option will survive the winter now depends less on Brussels and more on Washington. And, above all, whether America will remember which side it is supposed to defend.
Forbes
