AUDIT OFFICE - GAPS IN AUDITS, LACK OF IMPARTIALITY AND SERIOUS QUESTIONS ABOUT EVALUATIONS OF CULTURAL SPONSORSHIP - Filenews 18/11 by Giorgos Savvinidis
Serious weaknesses at almost different stages of managing the sponsorship programs of the Department of Contemporary Culture (TSP) of the Deputy Ministry of Culture are recorded by the Audit Office in its special report for the years 2024 and 2025. In 2026 is also in the picture, with the delayed approvals of sponsorships.
From the selection process of beneficiaries and the evaluation of applications to verifying expenditures and monitoring funded actions, the report identifies gaps that raise issues of transparency, equal treatment, and effective use of public resources.
The findings include sponsorships to entities that did not meet specific eligibility criteria, significant discrepancies in the evaluation committees' scores, cases of potential conflicts of interest, as well as deficiencies in the documentation of income and expenses. In two cases of documents, serious questions are raised regarding their authenticity and reliability.
The report does not concern the entire funding. The review focused on the "Cypriot" program for the years 2024 and 2025 and the subprograms "Music" and "Theater" of the sponsored program "Culture II" for 2025. Institutional sponsorships to cultural organizations to cover operating expenses were excluded, as they were subject to separate audit by the Audit Committee.
Funding outside eligibility conditions
Among the notable findings is the payment of a €50,000 sponsorship under "Cyprus 2025" to an organization classified as a recognized charitable foundation, which was explicitly excluded from the program's terms.
Additionally, two organizations were funded, despite having received written warnings from the District Administration since 2021 about a possible dissolution process due to non-compliance with the legislation governing their operation. The sponsorships involved amounts of €15,000 in 2024 and €20,000 and €35,000 in 2025. The Audit Office points out that the relevant information was available in the public registry of the Ministry of the Interior and should have been sought before the applications were approved.
In the 'Music' subprogram of 'Culture II,' five applications were also identified, totalling €74,036, for which the statutes of the organizations did not substantiate that their main activity involved music, as required by the terms of the plan.
Different scores, different treatment
Of particular interest are the observations on the evaluation process and the allocation of available funds.
In "Cypriot 2025," the available credits were sufficient to fund the first 14 applications based on ranking. However, applications were ultimately funded up to the 18th position, following a recommendation to include at least one proposal from the folk-traditional culture sector, which was in that position. The Audit Office notes that the decision was not sufficiently substantiated and that the announcement did not provide for mandatory representation of the specific sector.
In another case, an application initially rejected by "Culture-Music" was funded after repeated communications by the organization over a period of about six months. To enable its financing, credits that had been committed for another project that was not implemented were utilized. The organization was the second runner-up, resulting in the first being funded to maintain the ranking order.
The Audit Office also finds cases where, after initially approved proposals were cancelled, applicants with lower scores were selected, while there was another with higher scores that was not funded, without sufficient justification.
Score discrepancies are equally telling. Two applications with identical reviewer comments scored 80% and 93% respectively. In another case, two group evaluation forms for the same action ended with different final scores, 85.66% and 94.68%, despite the same reasoning. Score corrections were also identified without sufficient justification and inconsistencies between individual and group evaluations.
Conflicts of interest and problematic documentation
Cases raised real or potential conflicts of interest were recorded in the Evaluation Committees. Among other things, a member of the "Cypriot 2025" committee evaluated a body on whose Board of Directors he held until the date his appointment was announced. The same member also evaluated another body with which he had previous professional cooperation, without these relationships being disclosed at the time of appointment or evaluation.
In another case, a committee member of "Cypriot 2024" evaluated an application for a festival in which she participated as an artist the following year. Additionally, a member of the 2025 committee, while declaring a conflict of interest due to the participation of a first-instance relative in specific applications and refraining from their evaluation, continued to evaluate other applications that were directly competitive to them.
The process for submitting confidentiality and non-conflict of interest declarations was also problematic. For "Cypriot 2024," the declarations were signed in July 2025, almost a year and a half after the evaluation was completed. At "Culture II," a representative of the Hellenic Chamber of Commerce who participated in the Evaluation Committees did not sign a confidentiality statement, and similar statements were not signed by the members of the Objections Committee either.
On the financial side, the Audit Office finds that the TSP does not receive the documents documenting the financial statements and does not conduct random audits. Certification is carried out by external auditors of the entities, but without a clearly defined framework regarding the scope and methodology of their audit.
To determine the extent of the problem, the Audit Office examined receipts from ten entities funded through the "Kypria" program, five for 2024 and five for 2025. In at least six of the ten cases, indications were found that not all revenues had been adequately declared or documented, including tickets, other sponsorships, and sales of food and drinks.
In one case, zero ticket revenue was confirmed, despite publicly available data for their distribution through an electronic platform.
Even more serious questions arise from two cases of documentation. In 2025, invoices with electronically affixed signatures were submitted, without evidence that their authenticity was verified. In 2024, invoices and payment receipts were identified from different partners or suppliers with continuous numbering, although it was expected that an independent order would be maintained by each issuer.
The Audit Office itself clarifies that these findings do not by themselves prove forgery or other irregularities, but they raise reasonable doubts and require further investigation by the Audit Office.
At the same time, at least 11 organizations in 2024 and another 10 in 2025 submitted applications to both "Kypria" and "Culture II." No systematic checks were found for possible overlap of joint expenditure between the two programs. This does not mean that double funding was proven, but that there were insufficient safeguards to exclude the associated risk.
2026 and the day after
Although the audit period covers the years 2024 and 2025, the Audit Office makes a special reference to 2026 as well. As he notes, the approvals of applications for all TSP sponsorship programs were announced around mid-May, resulting in activity being limited during the first half and a significant portion of the activities being postponed to the second, under increased time pressure.
The Service estimates that the reduced implementation time may negatively affect the quality of cultural activities, as opportunities for timely planning, securing artists and collaborators, and attracting supplementary sponsorships are limited.
However, there is also a positive development recorded in the same report. In the "Cypriot" program, the time to complete the evaluation was reduced from 84 days in 2024 to 59 in 2025 and 38 in 2026. This improvement concerns this specific program and does not negate the overall delays observed in the 2026 sponsorship programs.
Another issue that remains open concerns the evaluation of grants by the Office of the State Aid Control Commissioner. Following a letter from the Office in November 2025, the "Culture," "Thymeli," and "Cypriot" programs were once again examined as to whether they fall under state aid rules. At the time of the audit, the process was pending, while the TSP stated that the matter was being handled by the Deputy Ministry of Culture.
The Audit Office recommends, among other things, the establishment of unified conflict of interest declarations before the start of evaluations, mandatory observance of records, preliminary eligibility checks by TSP officials, the establishment of cultural impact measurement indicators, and the conduct of random checks on receipts.
The response of the PSP regarding the findings
The Department of Contemporary Culture responds, for its part, that over the past three years there has been an ongoing effort to redesign the system, aiming to consolidate the individual plans into larger and more comprehensive programs. It also argues that several of the Audit Office's recommendations have already been set in motion or are in the implementation stage, while clarifications were provided on certain issues in the initial draft that were deemed sufficient.
The TSP recognizes the need to further improve the management framework of the grant programs and describes in its response letter a series of actions currently underway or planned. The letter responds to six key themes highlighted by the audit: the evaluation of program effectiveness, their redesign, management and control mechanisms, delays, the possibility of state aid issues, and archiving.
Regarding the evaluation of effectiveness, the TSP states that it collects data from evaluation reports, statistical data, and reports from the stakeholders, while also emphasizing that cultural impact cannot be assessed solely by quantitative indicators. However, it intends to define key indicators by program, improve data collection and processing, and strengthen systematic evaluation.
For the grant redesign, the Department describes the transition to broader and more coherent programs, with unified criteria, better management of available appropriations, and simplification of procedures. It also states that it promotes strengthening internal control mechanisms, with instruction manuals, standardized forms and control tools, preliminary checks of applications, and more systematic monitoring of the implementation of subsidized actions.
Is funding an end in itself?
Beyond the specific procedural weaknesses, the report opens a broader discussion about how the state perceives and evaluates support for cultural creation.
The Audit Office observes that many festivals remain unprofitable even after the sponsorship has been paid, while some organizations have consistently relied on state support. For this reason, it recommends assessing the financial adequacy of applicants and considering a minimum cost coverage rate from own resources or other secured sources.
However, the issue cannot be examined solely in economic terms. Public funding is a key tool of cultural policy, and the sustainability of an artistic activity does not necessarily coincide with its commercial autonomy. Supporting small groups, festivals with limited audiences, young creators, or actions with educational and social impact cannot be evaluated solely on their ability to secure private income.
Given this, the goal is not to limit state support, but to ensure that it is distributed in transparent and well-documented terms, that it meets the real needs of the cultural sector, and that it produces the result for which it is allocated.
The administrative leadership of the Deputy Ministry of Culture is now called upon to respond to the findings and present a specific timeline for implementing the corrective measures. The crucial question is whether the redesign of sponsorship programs will be accompanied by a substantial upgrade of inspections, as well as a more coherent policy treating public funding as an investment in culture rather than an expense to be limited.
